Friday, October 5, 2012

Butter Meltaways

Okay, so apparently "snarky know-it-all baker" is not one of my best faces...  I found this recipe on Pinterest and have been dying to try it.  I was bored one Saturday, so viola!  The kids were napping, Greg was doing homework, and the house needed to be cleaned.  Perfect opportunity to bake.  The laundry can wait... as it is right now.


I try to read through comments on recipes so I can make adjustments if people have problems.  One of the most frequent complaints was that the cookies crumbled.  About half of the people had no problems with the cookies, and 45% seemed to have crumbly cookies.  So, I made sure my butter was soft but not room temperature, I beat it until it was nice and "fluffy," and I watched them like a hawk when they were in the oven.  Came out beautifully.  "Tada!  Take that, you morons who don't know how to bake!  Mwahaha!"  Thought those nasties too soon.

First cookie off the sheet fell apart.  Don't get me wrong, it tasted great.  I am not above eating cookie crumbles.  I waited a few minutes and the second one crumbled, but not as bad.  (Full disclosure:  I burned my tongue eating the first cookie; it had been out of the oven about 4.2 seconds.)  So Nerd-Kristen came out immediately.  Turns out, if you let the cookies cool, they don't crumble much.  Huh? Whoduh thunk it?  Apparently not me.  Turns out if you let them cool a little longer than you think is unreasonable, they don't crumble at all.  It took all my willpower to let them sit on the cookie sheet.  Just wrong.


Here is the other part of my dilemma:  Greg and I ate about half the cookies BEFORE we iced them.  And it was cream cheese icing!  What?!?!  Yeah, that's how good they are.  I'm not entirely sure that Jeff even got one.  Sucks being two sometimes.

I really do recommend whipping the butter until it's fluffy and making sure your butter is soft but not room temperature.  However, as cruel as it may seem (unless you are not above eating crumbs), give the cookies some time to cool.  And then wait five more minutes.  You shouldn't have any problems.  Hope you're bored over the weekend and can try them!

Fluffy butter!
Dough, ready to cook
Butter Meltaways
Happily taken from LandeeSeeLandyDo.com (Thank you!  Thank you!  Thank you!)

Ingredients:
1 cup butter (2 sticks!!!)
3/4 cup cornstarch (yes, that IS correct)
3/4 cup powdered sugar
1 cup all purpose flour
cream cheese frosting (optional, but quite yummy)

Directions:
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.  In a medium bowl, cream butter until fluffy.  Add cornstarch and sugar, and blend well.  Beat in flour until thoroughly mixed.  Drop by tablespoons onto baking sheet.  Flatten with the bottom of a glass dipped in powdered sugar to prevent sticking.  Bake for 10-12 minutes.  Wait to remove cookies.  Wait some more.  Cool on wire rack and ice with cream cheese frosting if desired.

Cream Cheese Frosting
3 oz cream cheese, softened
1 cup powdered sugar
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
food coloring, optional

No comments:

Post a Comment